The Tribe

T
 

In a modern Ukrainian dystopia, a gang of deaf students acts out its rage against the world.

 Signing of the times

Myroslav Slaboshpytskiy's The Tribe does not go out of its way to seduce the mainstream viewer. There is no music, no voice-over, no dialogue and no subtitles. Set in a Kiev boarding school for the deaf, the film conveys all its communication in sign language, with the noise of the outside world dominating everything. Recalling the early oeuvre of Lars von Trier and Gaspar Noé, it is a fiercely original work whose ace card is its authenticity. Utilising genuinely non-professional deaf performers, Slaboshpytskiy goes to enormous pains to paint his grim world as realistically as possible. Many scenes require extraordinary commitment from the cast, baring all, doing everything. It’s a long shout from Children of a Lesser God and it would be fascinating to hear what the deaf think of it, as the director does not paint his characters in a favourable light. There isn’t a sentimental or gentle note in the film.

A sort of dumb Scum, the film stars Grygoriy Fesenko as Sergei, who turns up at his new school wide-eyed and wet-behind-the-ears, but who quickly takes to the life of crime spelled out to him. Much like Gus Van Sant’s Elephant, there is a lot of strolling down corridors and the inmates of the institution seem to be in a constant rush to get to their next illicit assignation. There’s a whiff, too, of The Lord of the Flies and If..., as if the students are hermetically sealed from the outside world, only colliding with it in order to scoop up another victim.

If The Tribe starts slowly, and is often as good as incomprehensible, it gathers momentum as we become accustomed to the characters and the fact that nothing will be spelled out. One scene in particular is quite startling – not because it is sexual or violent – but because it reveals real citizens speaking real Ukrainian. It is certainly a one-off and is unlikely to be forgotten in a hurry, whether or not one embraces its gimmickry.

Ukrainian title: Plemya.

JAMES CAMERON-WILSON

Cast
: Grygoriy Fesenko, Yana Novikova, Roza Babiy.

Dir Myroslav Slaboshpytskiy, Pro Iya Myslytska and Valentyn Vasyanovych, Screenplay Myroslav Slaboshpytskiy, Ph Valentyn Vasyanovych, Pro Des Vlad Odudenko, Ed Valentyn Vasyanovych, Costumes Alena Gres.

Garmata Film Production/Ukrainian Film Agency/Hubert Bals Fund/Development of Ukraine-Metrodome.
131 mins. Ukraine/The Netherlands. 2014. Rel: 15 May 2015. Cert. 18.

 
James Cameron-Wilson

Film critic, broadcaster and wordsmith. Forbidden from watching movies as a child, James decided to be a professional film critic and began reviewing for What's on in London in 1976. He has since reviewed for Sky TV, BBC radio, Talk Radio, the What's On Magazine Group, Film Review, The Times, The Sunday Times, Filmstar, Flicks, The London Paper, The Mirror, Photoplay, Ritz Newspaper, Shivers, Showbiz, TVTimes and more. He has published twenty-six books, including twenty editions of the Film Review annual, The Index, Young Hollywood, Hollywood: The New Generation, CinéStars, and The Cinema of Robert De Niro. James has been reviewing the major new releases on Share Radio’s The Business of Film, with Simon Rose firing the questions for over ten years and 600 episodes. James has been a member of the London Film Critics’ Circle since 1991 and has served as a board member of the Film Awards’ panel.

https://filmreviewdaily.com/james-cameron-wilson
Previous
Previous

Triangle of Sadness

Next
Next

A Trip to the Moon